Bow Tie Law

Ethics of e-Discovery (or, Teaching Lawyers Ballet)

“Watching an incompetent lawyer is like watching a clumsy ballerina.”  Magistrate Judge John M. Facciola, February 4, 2009  Magistrate Judge John M. Facciola’s keynote at Legal Tech 2009 had a call to action for lawyers to have certifications and standards of competence regarding technology.  In light of how everyday life[…]

Read more

Playing with Fire: Producing ESI as Paper

“…Revonet’s producing the e-mails only in hard copy played with fire. ” Magistrate Judge John Facciola, Covad Communications Company v. Revonet, Inc.  I have blogged on parties failing to state a form of production in prior postings and producing parties attempting to produce ESI as paper or non-searchable TIFFs.   In[…]

Read more

What Happens When the Requesting Party Does Not State a Form of Production?

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure Rule 34 allows for a requesting party to state the form of production in their request. In the event a requesting party does not state the form of production, the responding party can state the form of production in their reply. However, if no party[…]

Read more